Risk of tsunamis in Mediterranean Sea has been overstated

A review of geological evidence for tsunamis during the past 4500 years in the Mediterranean Sea has revealed that as many as 90 per cent of these inundation events may have been misinterpreted by scientists and were due to storm activity instead.

Boulders on the Tipaza coast of Algeria that would have been deposited in a high-energy event. Credit: C. Morhange.

“Understanding the true incidence of devastating tsunamis is vital for assessing the current risk and introducing appropriate protective strategies for densely populated coastal cities,” says study senior author and UNSW scientist Honorary Professor James Goff.

“Yet discriminating between tsunamis and storm deposits is one of the most challenging and hotly debated areas of coastal geoscience.

“Following intense media coverage of events like the devastating 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, there has been a marked increase in geological research reporting evidence for past tsunamis in the Mediterranean.

 “Our provocative and timely study suggests that up to 90 per cent of the claims for tsunamis having occurred in the Mediterranean in the past 4500 years need to be reconsidered. The risk from this hazard could have been significantly overstated in this region,” Professor Goff says.

The study, by an international team of scientists from UNSW, the French National Centre for Scientific Research, and the universities of Toulouse, Aix-Marseille and Exeter, is published in the journal Science Advances.

A big boulder on the Tipaza coast of Algeria that would have been deposited in a high-energy event. Credit: C. Morhange.

About 130 million people live around the Mediterranean Sea and it is one of the world’s leading tourist destinations, with more than 230 million visitors a year.

Geological evidence for past tsunamis includes the presence of large boulders on rocky coastlines, coarse sedimentary deposits in coastal lagoons, and high-energy marine deposits a long way inland.

The team studied 135 past events in eight Mediterranean countries that had been identified in the scientific literature as tsunamis on the basis of geological evidence, and which had been dated using a variety of scientific techniques.

“We compared these events with storm records for the same period,” says study first author Dr Nick Marriner of the French National Centre for Scientific Research.

“We found the dates for the tsunamis peaked every 1500 years – at about 200, 1600 and 3100 years ago. This matched well with 1500-year climate cycles of cooling in the Mediterranean and North Atlantic and heightened storm activity.

“This suggests most of the geological evidence is related to periods of severe storms, rather than tsunamis.”

Santorini in Greece. Image: Simm/Creative Commons

The Mediterranean is famous for one of the most catastrophic tsunamis of all time – the tsunami caused by the Santorini eruption almost 3500 years ago that devastated the civilisation of Crete, leading to the legend of the lost city of Atlantis.

It has numerous large waterfront cities, including Barcelona, Naples, Algiers, Istanbul and Tel Aviv.

Media contacts:
Professor James Goff: j.goff@unsw.edu.au  

UNSW Science media: Deborah Smith: 9385 7307, 0478 492 060, deborah.smith@unsw.edu.au